>>7628>it could've taken off to the extent that Fate did but for whatever reason it didn't quite get thereI am also talking out of my ass, but I think it has to do with accessibility and target audience. While Fate is of a similar length, I think it feels less intimidating when each route of FSN is pretty decent, and you get exactly what you expected. Meanwhile, people interested in the war drama aspect of Muv-Luv have to tolerate two VNs in a completely different genre before getting to the 'good part.' Additionally, prior to Fate, TYPE-MOON had created Tsukihime and related VNs; Fate is not terribly different tonally or thematically from Tsukihime, so if you like Tsukihime, you'll like Fate. Meanwhile, although age was no stranger to darker themes, they didn't venture into "war drama
utsuge with alien invasion and extensive science and military minutiae" territory before MLA. Kiminozo and KimiIta are their most famous titles prior to Muv-Luv, in my opinion, and while Extra and Unlimited fit with these two tonally, Alternative doesn't. I once read that a lot of Extra/Unlimited fans were disappointed by Alternative when it initially released in Japan, probably because it's entirely linear and
it doesn't have a happy ending. We take Muv-Luv's premise for granted now, but it was unexpected when it released; age probably alienated some of their core audience with it. Finally, Fate got another huge boost from its good anime adaptation. It helps that FSN is not horribly difficult to adapt if you just focus on one route instead of whatever Studio Deen was trying to do. Muv-Luv is far from impossible to adapt, but it would take a lot of patience and more time than what was afforded to Fate (the UBW anime is 26 episodes and adapts 1/3 of Fate in a complete and satisfactory story, whereas a Muv-Luv anime would need to adapt the whole thing in one go or else it wouldn't make sense).
>last time I heard about this franchise in the wild is when youtube recs showed me a video about a Muv-luv gacha that imploded in record time.Don't forget about the godawful 2021-2022 anime adaptation that speedran the first 2 VNs in the series and threw uninitiated people into Alternative with absolutely no context while also alienating the VN's audience by changing the
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.