/f/ - Fandom Generals

>Tiny altchan
>Still fucking 90% Nusona
God, fuck OFF.

>>3112
It's a single thread chill. Please make a thread on /f/ for whatever franchise you like.

>>3112
>why are people posting about the longer, modern, more accessible games which are on nearly every fucking platform instead of the 20+ year old games with questionable localization that you can’t play outside of emulation??!?!?!!
nonna, i love p2 and wish that there were more pre-p3 fans with all my heart, but this is just embarrassing.

>>3114
P1 did eventually get a better localization for one of the portable Playstation systems but it's still just not that fun. Great characters, but it's a slog to get going and imo doesn't do the best job explaining it's rpg mechanics. After you get like 10 hours in it does get better, but I think it would have benefited from the flashy remake compared to yet another P3 one.

Both P2s hold up fine and I don't get why they aren't more popular.

>>3115
Like >>3114 said, accessibility. To play P2 in english, you play IS on the psp and then EP on ps1, which requires two different emulators and is an awkward jump back in game tech. Alternatively, you could play both on ps1 with the IS translation hack or recently, the psp translation hack of EP that came out a few years ago. It's a lot of hoops to jump through to play a game. I suppose you could always play EP first, but most people nowadays wouldn't like to play a game out of order unless that's how it was originally released.

>>3116
I bought a PS1 copy for PS3 when they sold all the old SMT games on PSN. So there's that. I think PSN shut down on the PS3 two years ago however.

>>3856
But the real question is did you enjoy them?

>>3858
I blind played Eternal Punishment not knowing it was the second and got about 3 hours in before telling myself I'd finish but never did.

That said, what I did play was fun with an incredible OST and cool set up . A shame the PSP version of the OST is on Spotify and not the PS original because whatever the fuck they did to the instruments is actual horseshit

reviving the thread because of p4r announcement, wahoo. any predictions?

>>4361
i doubt they will change much in the remake, including the dungeons. the only potential change i could see is naoto's arc. considering that in 13 sentinels, a game published by atlus they made a gay boy nonbinary because he was disguising himself as a girl, i would not be surprised if they would do the same with naoto.
really, the only thing i want to see is yosuke wearing a skirt in glorious 4k, i don't care about anything else.

In Japan right now there's a lot of discussion about how they're going to make Yosuke "Reiwa friendly" (because he's a raging homophobe) and the most popular suggestion is just to reinstate his scrapped romance route, kek.

I'm so conflicted right now, I have been objecting to remakes for years but Persona 4 is one of my favorite games of all time so I'm actually really hyped. Apparently Yuri Lowenthal confirmed he isn't coming back as Yousuke so it looks like the EN dub has a whole new cast, I didn't buy P3R for the reason listed above lol, did that game recast the JP I know they did for the EN.

Anyway Adachi/Doujima has been my OTP forever I love them dearly if nothing else I'm sure the scenes of Adachi helping Doujima home will be cute in HD.

>>4362
I doubt they'll change anything about Naoto, or even Kanji. I heard P3 Reload didn't change anything from the original P3 except add a few gameplay features from FES and the post game with Aigis is a DLC because fatlus is insane. I'm not looking forward to the exact same discourse restarting again though. I doubt I'll play the remake anyway, I have too many games in my backlog right now and I don't trust Atlus all that much anymore.

>really, the only thing i want to see is yosuke wearing a skirt in glorious 4k, i don't care about anything else.
Me too. I've seen Japanese people joking that we'll probably have his romance scenes/SL too but even if that doesn't happen I hope the game will bully him at least as much as the original and there will be the same costumes from P4G during battles.

>>4363
kek I saw them spamming the word "compliance" so much today to talk about Yosuke. P4 is a product of its time so it would be weird if Yosuke became way more open minded right off the bat though. If he becomes a love interest it will more explicitly negate how he annoys the fuck out Kanji at first I guess the same way Vincent turned bi in Catherine Fullbody.

>>4364
>did that game recast the JP I know they did for the EN.
No, doing that is very uncommon in Japan. It's so uncommon that Atlus didn't want to replace Igor's voice actor who's been there since the P1 or P2 drama CD after his death and it became the inspiration for a massive plot point in P5. I have no idea how they'll handle Igor in P6 because of this. Maybe they'll replace him with Philemon and reuse the same recorded lines as usual? By the way Dojima's Japanese voice actor died a few years ago too so he'll either be replaced or Atlus will simply reuse his lines from P4 and P4G.

>>4365
>If he becomes a love interest it will more explicitly negate how he annoys the fuck out Kanji at first
Why would that be? To me Yosuke would read as a closet case that's trying to compensate and put on a heterosexual front by being mean to the guy he perceives to be a fag. If anything Yosuke's romantic route makes sense

It's a shame about all the original cast being replaced like P3R. It makes me wonder if there's some frustration about it with the VAs, especially with Yuri Lowenthal spoiling the game before it was even formally announced.

I personally don't have high hopes after how lazy they were last time. P3R had some of the worst lighting and unfinished textures I've seen in a while for a full-price game, and I'm worried they'll try to make the Golden content the extra DLC of this version.

All I want is the accomplice end and a moody, fog-laden Inaba.

>>4366
Yes that's exactly what I mean. His behavior with Kanji already looks like he's projecting a little, if we can date Yosuke that would be even more obvious.

>>4365
>post game with Aigis is a DLC
they'll do the same with marie
i doubt the discourse will restart because everyone who wanted to play p4 has played it already, it's available on every modern platform. there won't be a new influx of players like with p3r cause it was stuck on the ps2. it is for this reason i wish atlus would have remade p1 or p2 instead of p4, a modern gamer can't easily access them without emulators but i understand it's riskier. if they add nusona elements like social links then oldfags would complain but if they leave the games unchanged then newfags won't be interested.
in the poll for most wanted remakes atlus did a couple years ago p2 and p1 were second and third place respectively but atlus just skipped them and went straight to remaking p4 and raidou LOL, they would rather take the risk of losing the korean market to release raidou remaster than to even attempt remaking p1 and p2. forever doomed to obscurity…

>>4372
If Atlus remakes DDS1 and 2 and Persona 2 IS and EP I'll trust them again. For now I'm sure the P4G exclusive content will be in a DLC like you said and while I really dislike Marie and won't even get P4R it just shows how greedy Atlus currently is.

>>4373
>>4372
Honestly besides the Adachi social link I can't think of anything added in P4G that I'd consider essential P4 content. If you make Marnie DLC I'm not sure how you'd elegantly introduce her at post-game I feel like you'd have to re-write a bit of her story if you're not going to have her chilling in the Velvet Room all game. She's easily worst girl though and I wouldn't mind if they just didn't bring her back.

I jist want to say "Rerun" would be a much better subtitle for the game since it matches the TV aesthetic. Revival just sound generic.

>>4392
Revival is also a TV term.

>In television, a revival is a television series that returns to produce new episodes after being off the air for a certain amount of time, particularly due to cancellation.

>>4394
Oh you're right, I guess I associate it more with resurrection but that definition fits.

>>4392
I saw someone calling it Persona 4 Rewind as a joke before the real title was announced and after the remake was leaked, it would have works as well imo.

>>4361
super excited for the remake. my only concern is the soundtrack, i hope they don't remix the original osts too much

not a big yu/yosuke shipper myself but having a romance SL would be a step in the right direction for the franchise. it would be great if other males were romanceable too though. not that i have high hopes for atlus doing any of this though

Supposedly there were playtests for an early Persona 6 beta happening in the US and Japan this month.

The bits and pieces I've heard thus far seem … interesting, but I'm a bit concerned that we're just going to retread the last 3 games. Has anyone else heard the rumors?

>>4531
Oh I've been completely out of the loop and I haven't looked at /pg/ for a while. Care to enlighten me nonna?

>>4531
>but I'm a bit concerned that we're just going to retread the last 3 games. Has anyone else heard the rumors?
I haven't heard the rumors but if they stick to the same basic formula that wouldn't surprise me in a 'If it's not broken, don't fix it' sort of way since that applies to other long-running franchises like Dragon quest and Pokemon too.

>>4533
Yeah, and I prefer 3-5 to the more SMT like early titles. My main hope is that they have a slightly more mature plot. 5's Adults vs teens is a bit eye roll inducing.

>>4534
It's a difficult subject for me. As someone who enjoyed the Ocarina of time 3D zelda formula and the Paper mario TTYD formula these series kinda lost me when they switched things up. At the same time I also understand why BotW became a thing and why the next 4 paper mario games weren't the TTYD formula again because sometimes a formula does get stale. As someone who got into the persona series in 2023 with the steam ports it really feels like 5 perfected the gameplay that began in 3 so I wouldn't mind if they kept with it cause I don't think I'd feel burnt out on it yet personally but I suppose it depends. As much as "I wish they were in college" is a stereotypical opinion now I do feel like japanese high school on its own is overdone.

>>4535
Interesting you should mention Zelda because I agressively dislike the gameplay of BOTW for being so different but it brought more people to the series so I consider it a net positive overall. I got into the Persona with Golden on Vita but regardless of when you got into it it's obvious Persona has small incremental changes not huge ones, and that's fine! Going back to P3 and not being able to control party members for instance, or P5s graphical overhaul and gorgeous UI every Atlus game since has followed suit with. You should always be trying to make a better game, but at the same time if it ain't broke…

I'm not one of those "Persona needs to have an adult protagonist" fans, but I think 5 just feels incredibly juvinile compared to the rest all of the except 2 have an "adults are useless" lens to them but 5 is the only one that makes it the central tenet of the game.

>>3114
>>3116
Why are you acting like its hard to find and download an emulator?

I'm not part of that earlier conversation but I've started looking into persona 1 and 2 as well. I'm the type of person who heavily prefers to play older games on original hardware but secondhand prices are too high for me so I'll just have to get custom firmware onto my PSP.

>>4545
If you have a Vita I think there is still a roundabout way to purchase them that way, but yeah no idea why they aren't up on steam it's absolutely ridiculous. 1 is a bit archaic but 2 could easily get new fans if you sold them as a bundle.

>>4546
Thanks for the tip! I did buy a secondhand PS vita some time ago for a bunch of the exclusives I was interested in and I'm happy to have two more justifications for my purchase.

so is the gay mod for p5r good?

>>4532
>>4533

Take this with a large grain of salt, since everything I know is from a private IRC.
Supposedly they're leaning harder on the occult themes again, with a series of would-be murders that take place in a high school. The protag joins an extra-curricular squad again, sponsored by the police directly to enter a large dungeon that is based on the underworld.
The person claiming to know someone who went to the playtest said it was a VERY early beta and the game will likely not be ready until 2027. Most of the cutscenes were just storyboards. They also mentioned that Midori's 'leaks' were correct about the game's color being a bright green.

Seems most of the people in the US playtest were normies, so not much ended up getting leaked. I don't know how much I personally believe. Here's hoping some actual evidence slips eventually, because there were other interesting details I'd love to confirm.

>>4612
>other details i'd like to confirm
like what?

>>4602
it was just okay in my opinion. it depends whos romance SL you're planning to do. it's worth a download regardless

>>4612
>Seems most of the people in the US playtest were normies, so not much ended up getting leaked.
unfortunate

please share more info if you have any nonna! i'd love to know more

>>4612
>sponsored by the police directly
I know the english fandom would have a collective meltdown over this, so I'm sure it's likely real kek considering the p-team always involves police eventually as some form of good guys (kurosawa in P3, chie wanting to join the police, makoto also doing the same).
It's weird though that if it's true that there's not a single normie that knows Persona at all, really?

>>4620
>there's not a single normie that knows Persona at all
i find that hard to believe. anyone with an even passing interest in vidya would have heard of p5 and both p3r and metaphor sold 2 million copies.

>>4612
> Midori's 'leaks' were correct about the game's color being a bright green
i mean, this was essentially confirmed in the 25th anniversary art with the random green paint bucket anyway lmao, i don't think atlus was being subtle there

>>4620
>>4621

Imagine a group of people who are mostly involved in casual properties, or have a very passing interest to begin with. Those chosen went in blind and only knew they were being paid for a few hours of their time with a game (approx $200, which would attract anyone). It seems like the focus was on seeing the reactions from a more general population. The person who attended knew what Persona was, but didn't think much of it until the IRC member started asking them more questions. They're someone who mostly played gacha and flavor of the month co-op games, and thought they were chosen for one of those.

>>4620
They said as much. A few who played mentioned not liking that they had to work alongside the police. Your initial navigator is a middle-aged cop who uses a drone persona to oversee the party, and one of your schoolmates is a Makoto/Mitsuru type who was employed by them before the MC arrived.


MC was described as having a blond bowl cut, and their 'underworld' uniform had a big puffy coat. His persona was a headless horseman kind of thing, and apparently unlike the other demons in the playable dungeon, it couldn't be fused with anything else 'for story reasons'. The battle system is a bit different, and now enemies have a 'veil' that you need to break with ailments or certain attacks prior to hitting any weaknesses. I hope this part is true, because ailments in P4/5 were mostly useless.

They also said the dungeon progression involved an investigation where you'd have to find clues about who was trapped in it, and who lured them there. The first boss is another persona-user, but theirs wasn't modeled for the fight. When someone disappears to the underworld a monument of them appears in the real world with candles, and when the candles go out the person will die. Heavy occult vibes. The investigations required evidence, and there was a stat called confidence that would go down if you were wrong when presenting it during the story progression.

Still all hearsay, but it seemed in line with modern Atlus' trajectory to me. That's why I'd love some actual confirmation, but with no-phone policies in testing, it'll probably be a while.

>>4623
god please no blond bowlcut that does not sound cute or appealing

>>4624
But we do have cute bowl cuts already in the Megaten universe, just make it black and I'm all for it.

>is persona was a headless horseman kind of thing, and apparently unlike the other demons in the playable dungeon, it couldn't be fused with anything else 'for story reasons'
I wonder if this was just for the demo, I can't imagine getting far enough to fully engage with the summoning system, I wonder if it was just locked for playtesting.

>>4624
BEBECHADS RISE UP

>>4623
interesting. ty for sharing anyway

>>4625

Fusion WAS included, but they didn't interact with it much since they liked the main persona and it was enough to power through the dungeon without issue. Igor was there as usual, but they said the person with him (possibly the attendant) was a young girl who had bolts ala Frankenstein and was wearing mostly black.

You gained new demons by arresting them post-battle, but they weren't very specific about it since they apparently ignored that too.

>>4626
>>4624
Forgot to mention MC fights with two swords, and has a hopping idle animation in battle that was 'kinda cute'. This could make it better or worse, but they compared him to Ryo from Devilman Crybaby in general appearance.

I'm trying to remember what else is important enough to mention without spamming the board. The most notable social link was another student who is trying to become an influencer to bring business to her grandmother's street food stand. The link involved them arguing over it, and the girl trying not to let online pressure get to her. She had a 'cute street style' and pink gradient hair.

The victim in the dungeon was regarded as a piano prodigy, and the persona-using boss throws him in because he's jealous over it. During the boss fight, he transforms into full Gene Simmons makeup. The playtest ended once he was defeated.

>>4628
>Igor was there as usual, but they said the person with him (possibly the attendant) was a young girl who had bolts ala Frankenstein and was wearing mostly black.
Not surprised, all the attendants and Igor himself, and even Viktor and Mary inthe Devil Summoner series are specifically named after Frankenstein characters. I wonder what will happen with Igor. It's so obvious that P5 was written around his Japanese voice actor's death that I assume the devs don't want to replace him no matter what with the fake Igor having his own voice actor and are willing to just reuse his previous lines. So I assume the attendant will have more lines in comparison. When is Philemon coming back?

>The victim in the dungeon was regarded as a piano prodigy, and the persona-using boss throws him in because he's jealous over it.
It's basically like in Tartarus and the Memento then. Same thing with the police actively being involved in what's going on, there are always police officers or detectives involved in the series since P2 at the very least. I haven't played P1 so maybe that's also true for this game. I get being disappointed or surprised if playtesters don't know Persona but I know some Persona fans will seethe.

>>4623
>Heavy occult vibes
I'm sold. I just hope Atlus won't take too much time releasing the game so I can get it on the PS5, I don't plan on getting more recent consoles for plenty of reasons after that.

>>4628
everything sounds like it could be real except for the part about the attendant wearing mostly black.
they're supposed to mostly wear blue.